Cattle in field

Author(s): Greg Halich and Kenny Burdine

Published: March 18th, 2021

Shareable PDF


After a tough couple weeks in February, it is looking a lot more like spring in Kentucky. Spring means stocker operators are looking to place calves on pasture for summer and is the time of year when we typically see our seasonal highs in the calf market. As of mid-March 2021, calf prices had increased by more than $10 per cwt from their lows in the fall of 2020. At the time of this writing (March 16, 2020), fall 2021 CME© feeder cattle futures were trading in the mid-upper $150’s per cwt, which was roughly a $20 premium over the March contract.  This suggests an extremely large increase is expected for heavy feeder cattle prices between now and fall, which should bode well for calf prices as we move closer to grass growth. Some operations likely placed calves during the winter, with the intention of purchasing stockers before the typical spring price peak.  However, many more will place calves as pastures green up in the coming weeks.  It is imperative that stocker operators pay careful attention to the market, their costs, and what can be paid for stocker calves this spring.

The purpose of this article is to assess the likely profitability of summer stocker programs for 2021 and establish target purchase prices for calves based on a range of return levels.  While it is impossible to predict where feeder cattle markets will end up this fall, producers need to estimate this and not rely on the current price (March) for 750-850 lb feeder calves.  The fall CME© feeder cattle futures price (adjusted for basis) is the best way to estimate likely feeder cattle prices for fall.  Grazing costs including pasture costs, veterinary and health expenses, hauling, commission, etc. are estimated and subtracted from the expected value of the fall feeders.  Once this has been done, a better assessment can be made of what can be paid for stocker cattle this spring in order to build in an acceptable return to management, capital, and risk. 

Key assumptions for the stocker analysis are as follows: 1) Graze steers April 1 to October 1 (183 days), 1.5 lb/day gain (no grain feeding), 2% death loss, and 5% interest on the calf.  The interest rate used in this analysis may seem high for producers who are self-financed or have very low interest rates, but is likely pretty close for those going through traditional lenders.  Given these assumptions, sale weights would be 775 lbs and 875 lbs for 500 lb and 600 lb purchased calves, respectively.  Using a $157 CME© futures contract price for October 2021 to estimate sale price, a 775 steer is estimated to sell for $152.50 and an 875 steer is estimated to sell for $146.50.  This estimate uses a $6 per cwt basis for an 800 lb steer and a $6 per cwt price slide.  These sale prices are also based on the assumption that cattle are sold in lots of 40 or more head.  Stocker operators who typically sell in smaller lots should adjust their expected sale prices downward accordingly.

Estimated costs for carrying the 500 and 600 lb steers are shown in Table 1.  Stocking rates of 1.0 acre per 500 lb steer and 1.2 acres per 600 lb steer were assumed in arriving at these charges.  Most of these are self-explanatory except the pasture charge, which accounts for variable costs such as bush-hogging, fertilizer, seeding clovers, etc., and is considered a bare-bones scenario.  Sale expenses (commission) are based on the assumption that cattle will be sold in larger groups and producers will pay the lower corresponding commission rate.  However, producers who sell feeders in smaller groups will pay the higher commission rate which will likely be around $40 to $50 per head based on the revenue assumptions of this analysis.  Any of these costs could be much higher in certain situations, so producers should adjust accordingly.

 

Table 1: Expected Variable Costs 2021 for 500 and 600 lb steers

 

Target purchase prices were estimated for both sizes of steers and adjusted so that gross returns over variable costs ranged from $25-125 per head.  This gives a reasonable range of possible purchase prices for each sized calf this spring. Results are shown in Table 2.  For 500 lb steers, target purchase prices ranged from $1.83 to $2.03 per lb.  For 600 lb steers, target purchase prices ranged from $1.67 to $1.83 per lb.  When targeting a $75 per head gross profit, breakeven purchase prices were $1.93/lb for 500 lb steers and $1.75/lb for 600 lb steers. 

  

As an example of exactly how this works for a 500 lb steer targeting a $75 gross profit:

   775 lbs steer x $1.525 (expected sale price)          $1,182

   Total Variable Costs                                                - $141

   Profit Target                                                               - $75

  Target Purchase Cost                                                $966

Target Purchase Price = $966 / 500 lbs = $1.93 / lb

   

Table 2: Target Purchase Prices for Various Gross Profits 2021

 

For heifers, sale price for heavy feeders will be lower than comparably sized steers and they will not generally gain as well.  In this analysis, we assumed the price discount for these heifers is $8 per hundredweight lower than the same weight steers and we assumed heifers would gain 10% slower than steers.  With these assumptions, purchase prices would have to be $0.17/lb lower for 500 lb heifers and $0.15 lower for 600 lb heifers compared to the steer prices found in Table 2.  Thus when targeting a $75 per head gross profit, breakeven purchase prices were $1.76/lb for 500 lb heifers and $1.60/lb for 600 lb heifers. 

Your cost structure may be different from that presented in Table 1, and if so, simply shift the targeted gross profit up or down to account for this.  If your costs are $25 higher per calf, then you would shift each targeted profit down by one row: For example, you would use the $125 gross profit to estimate a $100 gross profit if your costs were $25 higher.  Another way to evaluate this is that a $1 increase in costs would decrease the targeted purchase price by $0.20 per cwt for 500 lb steers and $0.17 per cwt for 600 lb steers.

It is important to note that the gross profits in Table 2 do not account for labor or investments in land, equipment, fencing, and other facilities (fixed costs).  Thus, in the long-run, these target profits need to be high enough to justify labor and investment, as well as a management return.  Often, by the time this article is written in mid-March, calf prices are approaching levels that would place returns on the lower end of the range analyzed. However, current calf prices are well below many of the target purchase prices estimated in this analysis given fall CME© futures prices. This is all the more reason that stocker operators should carefully think through their budgets and make rational purchasing decisions.

There is a tendency for calf prices to reach their seasonal price peak when grass really starts growing in early spring.  There is little reason to think this won’t happen in 2021, which will result in tighter expected margins for stocker cattle placed in the upcoming weeks.  However, two unique factors are at play in 2021 that are worth discussion. First, there is an unusually large difference between the current prices for heavy feeder cattle and what the fall board is suggesting. Some stocker operators may be bidding less aggressively if they are planning their programs based on current heavy feeder prices, rather than future’s based fall expectations. Secondly, higher feed prices are likely discouraging feedlots from placing light calves on feed right now.  This would result in less competition in calf markets, which may be keeping calf prices somewhat at bay. While there is no way to know for sure what the next few weeks will bring, there could be significant opportunities for stocker operators to place calves at a favorable margin this spring.

Finally, the placement of calves into stocker programs represents a significant cost and there is always a great deal of uncertainty about fall sale price.  For this reason, stocker operators should also consider risk management strategies as they place calves into grazing programs. Hedging, through the sale of futures contracts, provides solid downside risk protection, but will subject the producer to margin calls if cattle prices increase.  Entering a cash forward contract or offering cattle through internet sales with delayed delivery will reduce or eliminate price uncertainty, but will also limit marketing flexibility should weather conditions necessitate sale at a different time. Finally, strategies such as put options and Livestock Risk Protection (LRP) Insurance offer a less aggressive strategy that provides downside price protection (at a price), but more ability to capitalize on rising prices. And, the subsidy levels for LRP insurance have increased substantially, making LRP more attractive than it has been in recent years. Regardless of what makes the most sense for the individual producer, time spent considering price risk management is likely time well spent in these volatile markets.  The best way to ensure profitability is to budget carefully and to manage downside price risk. 

 

Greg Halich is an Associate Extension Professor in Farm Management Economics for both grain and cattle production and can be reached at Greg.Halich@uky.edu or 859-257-8841.  Kenny Burdine is an Associate Extension Professor in Livestock Marketing and Management and can be reached at kburdine@uky.edu  or 859-257-7273.


Author(s) Contact Information: 

Greg Halich  |  Associate Extension Professor  |  greg.halich@uky.edu 

Kenny Burdine  |  Associate Extension Professor  |  kburdine@uky.edu

Recent Extension Articles


Cow-Calf Profitability Estimates for 2020 and 2021 (Spring Calving Herd)

February 25th, 2021

The purpose of this article is to examine cow-calf profitability for a spring calving herd that sold weaned calves in the fall of 2020 and provide an estimate of profitability for the upcoming year. Every operation is different, so producers should evaluate and modify these estimates to fit their situation. 

ARC-PLC Farm Bill Decision 2021

February 25th, 2021

Starting in 2018, grain farmers have had the ability to decide on a yearly basis between the ARC and PLC Farm Bill programs. In general, the decision for 2021 will not be nearly as important as in most years, as the likelihood for a payout with either program is fairly low with all crop-types.


Subscribe to our Economic & Policy Update Newsletter

Subscribe to our monthly Economic & Policy Update e-newsletter to receive our top articles straight to your inbox. 

  

Connect with Us

Facebook  |  @UKYAgEconTwitter  |  @UKYAgEconLinkedIn  |  @UKYAgEconYoutube  |  @UKYAgEcon